Alan Ladd plays the title character of "Shane" in George Stevens' classic western that marks the battle between the ranchers and the encroaching homesteaders.
A stranger passing by the Starrett farm, Shane is quickly pulled into the lives of Joe (Van Heflin), Marian (Jean Arthur), and their son Joey (Brandon De Wilde), and seemingly happy for it. Shane is a gunslinger. We are not really told this by dialogue, but rather see it by his side arm and by how he seems on edge, always alert.
Part of the magic of this film comes from what the movie SHOWS us, rather than a fancy dancy wordy script. Which is also fair to say about another of Stevens' great classics, a little film called "Giant". We see respect grow between Shane and Joe, we see how lost Shane feels, we see a building (but never acted upon) passion build between Shane and Marian. And we see the great state of Wyoming and understand why both the ranchers and the homesteaders would fight for her.
So what happens? The ranchers make strike after strike against the homesteaders, tying to scare them off. And it works for some. But yet others stay. Including the Starrett family. And Shane. Eventually they bring in a hot shot gunslinger, Wilson, (Jack Palance) to push the homesteaders even harder. The homesteaders argue that "God didn't make all this land for just one man!"
Eventually one of Starrett's friends is killed by Wilson, leading to Joe and Shane discussing facing him. Marian counters with "You're both out of your senses! This isn't worth a life! Anybodies life! What are we fighting for? This shack? This little piece of ground? And nothing but work work work?" Joe feels he must go face Wilson himself. Shane says no and the friends fight. It's a tough fight to watch, but in the end Shane ensures that he goes to face Wilson alone, protecting his friends, the Starrett's. Sometimes you want to walk away from your past, but it comes back nipping at your heals.
George Stevens had originally cast Montgomery Clift as Shane, and William Holden as Joe. Wouldn't that have been something?! When they both ended up picking different projects "Shane" was nearly abandoned. Stevens went to the studio head and asked who was available. Looking over a list he had the film cast in three minutes! His old friend Jean Arthur came out of semiretirement for this picture, which would be her last.
During the funeral scene the dog wouldn't look into the grave. So Stevens had the dogs trainer climb in. It worked! As they kept filming the scene they lowered in the coffin, weighted down with rocks. This was too so bad. But when the harmonica players stated playing Taps the extras started shoveling dirt in onto the poor trainer too!
During the fight between Shane and Joe the horses we supposed to act frightened. When they didn't Stevens had two men put on bear costumes to scare the horses. Makes watching the fight scene pretty funny!
Nominated for six Oscars, it walked away with only one: Best Cinematography. Only one, but a worthy one indeed! In 1954 the other Best Picture nominees included: The Robe, Julius Caesar, Roman Holiday, and the winner, From Here To Eternity. Steep competition!